Follow Jeff Sayre on Twitter

OAuth, BuddyPress, and Privacy


OAuthWhen I first started kicking around the idea of coding a privacy component for BuddyPress, several people suggested looking into using the OAuth protocol to accomplish the task. Being semi-omniscient, and totally oblivious to everything else, I did not have the faintest clue on how to work with OAuth.

After learning the rudimentary workings of OAuth, it quickly became clear that it did not offer a mechanism for internal access control, nor was it even intended to be used as an authorization protocol. I’ll discuss this last statement in more detail later.

So, to educate my fellow social media gurus, I decided it would be helpful to jot down what I learned and determined about OAuth, its intended use in any social media application like BuddyPress, and how privacy control needs to be implemented within BuddyPress.

What is OAuth?

From the OAuth Core 1.0 Specifications:

The OAuth protocol enables websites or applications (Consumers) to access Protected Resources from a web service (Service Provider) via an API, without requiring Users to disclose their Service Provider credentials to the Consumers. More generally, OAuth creates a freely-implementable and generic methodology for API authentication.

Therefore, OAuth is a set of rules and procedures that facilitate the exchange of data between websites without the requesting website requiring the user to provide his or her sensitive authentication credentials. This enables a greater level of security for all users.

Imagine if you had to provide your Twitter credentials (username and password) when installing the Twitter Facebook Application in your Facebook profile. Fortunately, Twitter now uses the OAuth protocol so your password does not need to be provided to and stored by Facebook. Instead, a token with defined rights is created and used by the Twitter Facebook Application to gain access to your Twitter data.

How Privacy Needs to be Implemented in BuddyPress

Whereas OAuth can provide access control to a user’s private data, or any URL with a need for access restrictions, it does so only between sites. OAuth is not a protocol used for internal access control; it is not an internal authorization protocol.

(Visit this post to learn more about Authentication Versus Authorization)

Again, from the OAuth Core 1.0 specification:

It is important to understand that security and privacy are not guaranteed by the protocol. In fact, OAuth by itself provides no privacy at all and depends on other protocols to accomplish that.

Therefore, BuddyPress requires its own internal privacy protocol. Enter, BPAz, my BuddyPress Privacy Component

BPAz is a necessary protocol for providing privacy to all BuddyPress users’ personal data. Once a given user’s data is sufficiently controlled by their BPAz access control list (ACL), they can feel more confident in exposing any data they wish to share across the Web.

BPAz is internal to a given BuddyPress install. It provides the mechanism whereby a give authenticated user can establish access rights—via an ACL—to their internal objects. The focus is on allowing users to have fine-grained control over their personal data. OAuth, on the other hand, is a protocol that facilitates the cross-site sharing of user content.Bpaz_OAuth

With BPAz, users can compartmentalize their data, to decide which pieces can be shared and with whom. OAuth can then generate tokens based on a given user’s ACL that allow clearly defined access rights to users in outside networks. Without the privacy filtering of BPAz, OAuth tokens would be very broad in scope, potentially allowing access to all of a user’s data with a single token.

Now, it is not as simple as installing my Privacy Component and suddenly your BuddyPress site is ready to safely communicate your users’ data to the outside world via OAuth. WPMU and BuddyPress first need to properly communicate with OAuth. This is on the roadmap for a future version. Once that happens, I will take a look at the code and figure out what, if any, I need to alter in my Privacy Component to properly communicate with OAuth.

So, the take home message is this. Authentication within BuddyPress is currently handled by a few internal core WPMU scripts. Authorization, however, is not yet a core feature of BuddyPress. My Privacy Component is an important first step in molding BuddyPress into a platform that can safely and effectively interact with other social media sites.

Article Comments

  1. Mark Pearson says:

    This is a hugely significant piece towards implementing an eportfolio with the BP-WPMU framework! Thanks

  2. Mark says:

    Is this system ever going to work well, currently janrain offers similar functionality but it sttill has problems, any dev going on here still?


Share on Twitter
Share on Facebook
Share on FriendFeed
Share on LinkedIn
Share on StumbleUpon
Share on Digg
Share on Delicious
Share on Technorati
Add to Google Bookmarks